Suffolk Office:
(631) 789-3476
Nassau Office:
(516) 741-3476
Emergency Number:
(516) 848-4649
AVAILABLE 24/7
Suffolk Office:
(631) 789-3476
Nassau Office:
(516) 741-3476
Emergency Number:
(516) 848-4649
AVAILABLE 24/7

Suffolk County Theft & Larceny Lawyer

A theft charge often starts with an accusation, not an arrest — an employer who says money is missing, a store that says you walked out with merchandise, a business partner or family member who calls a disagreement stealing. By the time the police are involved, someone else’s version of events is already written down. James Pascarella defends people charged with larceny, burglary, and other theft offenses in Suffolk County. He has practiced criminal law for 26 years.

The lawyer you choose matters. James does all the work on his cases himself, and criminal defense is all he does.

The charges

  • Petit larceny — a class A misdemeanor. Taking property worth $1,000 or less; shoplifting is usually charged this way.
  • Grand larceny — a felony, in four degrees. The degree rises with the value taken: over $1,000, over $3,000, over $50,000, over $1 million.
  • Burglary — entering a building unlawfully with intent to commit a crime inside; a felony, and a violent felony when the building is a home.
  • Robbery — taking property by force or threat of force; always a felony.
  • Criminal possession of stolen property — holding property you know was stolen, charged at the same value levels as larceny.

The number is the case

In a larceny case, one number decides almost everything: the value the prosecution puts on what was taken. A few hundred dollars either way can be the difference between a misdemeanor and a felony. And that number usually starts as the accuser’s number — the employer’s estimate, the store’s price tag, the partner’s claim — taken at face value. Values get inflated: retail price instead of actual value, new price for used property, totals that sweep in things that were never taken at all. James goes through the receipts, the records, and the math, and holds the prosecution to what it can actually prove the property was worth.

The other question is intent. Theft requires intent to steal. Money held in a genuine dispute, property taken under an honest belief it was yours, a business disagreement over who owed what — those are civil matters, and they get dressed up as criminal charges more often than they should, especially when the accuser wants leverage. A charge is not proof that a crime happened.

James’s results in theft cases include a grand larceny case that ended with no criminal conviction at all, and a burglary case where the client’s confession was suppressed after a hearing.

The courts

Theft charges in Suffolk County are heard in the district courts and, for felonies, in Suffolk County Court in Riverhead. James is in the Suffolk County courts almost every day.

Why hire James Pascarella

  • Former Assistant District Attorney — he knows how theft cases are charged and valued.
  • 26 years practicing criminal law; selected to Super Lawyers for ten years (2016–2026).
  • He does all the work on his cases himself.
  • He has tried hundreds of cases, in state and federal court.

Frequently asked questions

The amount they’re claiming is way more than anything I took. Does that matter?
It matters enormously — value sets the degree of the charge. The prosecution has to prove the amount, and an inflated figure is one of the first things a defense attacks.

It was a misunderstanding about money/property. Can I still be charged?
Yes — people get charged in genuine ownership and debt disputes. But theft requires intent to steal, and an honest claim of right is a defense.

Charged with larceny, burglary, or another theft offense in Suffolk County? Call James Pascarella for a free consultation — (631) 789-3476. In an emergency, call (516) 848-4649, answered 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.

Visit Us On FacebookVisit Us On Linkedin