An assault charge usually starts with the worst few minutes of a bad night — a fight outside a bar, an argument that got physical, a neighbor dispute that boiled over. By the time the police arrive, the fight is over, and what they see is not what happened. James Pascarella defends people charged with assault in Suffolk County, in the district courts and in County Court in Riverhead. He has practiced criminal law for 26 years.
The lawyer you choose matters. James does all the work on his cases himself, and criminal defense is all he does.
The charges
- Assault in the third degree — a class A misdemeanor. Intentionally or recklessly causing physical injury to another person.
- Assault in the second degree — a class D felony. Causing serious physical injury, or injury with a weapon or dangerous instrument.
- Assault in the first degree — a class B felony. Serious physical injury caused with a weapon, with intent.
The degree turns on two things: how badly someone was hurt, and what the prosecution says was used. Both can be challenged — and both are challenged more often than people realize.
Not every fight is an assault
Police who arrive at the end of a fight see the aftermath, not the beginning. Very often, the person arrested is simply the person who won the fight — the one still standing when the police pulled up. But winning a fight you did not start is not a crime. The person who threw the first punch, who kept coming, who made the other defend himself, is not always the one in handcuffs. Sorting out who was actually the aggressor is where these cases are won.
It also happens that the injury at the center of an assault charge grows in the telling. A complaint is written in the heat of the moment, and the injury described in it does not always match the photographs, the medical records, or what the person did in the days that followed. Sometimes, when the evidence is examined closely, there was no real assault at all. James goes through the records line by line — the medical file, the photos, the statements — and holds the prosecution to what it can actually prove.
Assault cases also rise and fall on self-defense, on witnesses who saw different things, and on video that tells a different story than the police report. All of it has to be gathered before it disappears.
The courts
Assault charges in Suffolk County are heard in the district courts and, for felonies, in Suffolk County Court in Riverhead. James is in the Suffolk County courts almost every day.
Why hire James Pascarella
- Former Assistant District Attorney — he knows how assault cases are charged and tried.
- 26 years practicing criminal law; selected to Super Lawyers for ten years (2016–2026).
- He does all the work on his cases himself.
- He has tried hundreds of cases, in state and federal court.
Frequently asked questions
I was defending myself. Can I still be charged?
Yes — self-defense is a defense at trial, not a shield against arrest. Police charge first and sort it out later, which is exactly why the investigation into who started it matters so much.
The other person wasn’t really hurt. Is it still assault?
It can still be charged — but the injury is an element the prosecution has to prove, and an exaggerated or unsupported injury claim is a real weakness in their case.
Charged with assault in Suffolk County? Call James Pascarella for a free consultation — (631) 789-3476. In an emergency, call (516) 848-4649, answered 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.