A DWI arrest anywhere on Long Island — Nassau County or Suffolk County — is a criminal charge, not a traffic ticket. A first offense is a misdemeanor. It can mean a fine, a revoked license, an ignition interlock device, and a criminal record — and your license is usually suspended at your very first court appearance, before the case is decided. In some circumstances the prosecutor could be looking for jail, and probation is also a possible outcome. What you do in the first days after the arrest matters, because the deadlines start running immediately. There is no right or wrong answer when it comes to taking the chemical test — it depends on the situation, and it is a decision to make with a lawyer, not alone on the side of the road. And if you have just been arrested, call me. My cell is (516) 848-4649, and if it is an emergency I do not care what time it is — 3 in the morning included. That is what the number is for.
James Pascarella is a former Assistant District Attorney with 26 years in criminal law, and he has tried hundreds of cases. Criminal defense is all he does. He appears in the Nassau courts and the Suffolk County courts almost every day, from his offices in Hauppauge (888 Veterans Memorial Highway, Suite 530) and Mineola (1551 Franklin Avenue). He has been selected to Super Lawyers for 11 years in a row, and to the National Trial Lawyers Top 100.
Long Island is two counties, two District Attorney’s offices, and dozens of local courts. A DWI case is handled differently in each of them — the court your case is in, the prosecutor across the table, and the local practices all depend on where the arrest happened. This page is the starting point: the charges and the process are the same across New York, and the county pages below carry the detail for where your case will actually be heard.
Start with your county
- Arrested in Suffolk County? Suffolk County DWI Lawyer — First District Court in Central Islip, Suffolk County Court in Riverhead, and the town and village courts, including the East End justice courts. Suffolk office: (631) 789-3476.
- Arrested in Nassau County? Nassau County DWI Lawyer — District Court in Hempstead, County Court in Mineola, and the village courts. Mineola office: (516) 741-3476.
- Want the penalties first? The First-Offense DWI Penalties in New York guide — sets out the fines, license consequences, and programs for a first offense, charge by charge. (The same guide is on the Nassau site.)
The DWI charges in New York
New York has several different impaired-driving charges, all charged under Vehicle and Traffic Law § 1192. Which one you face changes the penalties:
- Driving While Ability Impaired by Alcohol (DWAI), VTL § 1192(1). A blood alcohol content generally between .05% and .07%. A traffic infraction, not a crime — but it still carries a fine, a license suspension, and a mandatory Impaired Driver Program.
- DWI — per se, VTL § 1192(2). A blood alcohol content of .08% or higher, shown by a chemical test. A misdemeanor for a first offense.
- DWI — common law, VTL § 1192(3). Driving in an intoxicated condition, proven by observations and other evidence even without a breath or blood test result.
- Aggravated DWI, VTL § 1192(2-a). A blood alcohol content of .18% or higher. Still a misdemeanor for a first offense, but with higher fines and a longer license revocation.
- Driving While Ability Impaired by Drugs, VTL § 1192(4). Impairment by drugs, or by drugs combined with alcohol. A misdemeanor for a first offense, with the same penalty range as a DWI.
- Refusing the chemical test, VTL § 1194. Refusal is not itself a crime, but it triggers a separate DMV case: a one-year license revocation and a $500 civil penalty for a first refusal, on top of the criminal case.
- Felony DWI. A second DWI within 10 years is a felony. A DWI with a child under 16 in the vehicle is a felony even on a first offense, under Leandra’s Law.
Where Long Island DWI cases are heard
In Suffolk County:
- First District Court, Cohalan Court Complex, Central Islip — misdemeanor DWI cases, and the arraignment for most DWI arrests in the county. Your license is typically suspended at arraignment.
- Suffolk County Court, Riverhead — felony DWI cases, prosecuted here after indictment.
- Town and village courts — DWI arrests made by local police often start in the local court, including the East End justice courts in East Hampton, Southampton, Southampton Village, Southold, Shelter Island, and Quogue, where James worked as a young prosecutor and knows the local practices.
In Nassau County:
- Nassau County District Court, Hempstead — misdemeanor DWI cases, and most DWI arraignments, including the license suspension at arraignment.
- Nassau County Court, Mineola — felony DWI cases, prosecuted here after indictment, minutes from James’s Mineola office.
- Village courts — DWI arrests made by village police departments often begin in the village court where the arrest happened. The charge is the same; the court and the procedures are local.
Two cases at once: the criminal case and the DMV case
A DWI arrest starts two proceedings, and the second one moves faster:
- The criminal case — arraignment, discovery, and then resolution by plea or trial, in the court listed above for your county and charge.
- The DMV case — an administrative action against your license. Your license is typically suspended at arraignment if the test showed .08% or higher, or if you refused. If you refused the chemical test, you have only 15 days to request a DMV refusal hearing. Missing that deadline can cost you the hearing.
A conviction means a revocation, not a suspension: at least six months for a first DWI, at least one year for a first aggravated DWI. A conditional license through the Impaired Driver Program can allow limited driving for work, school, and medical appointments, but it is not automatic — whether you qualify depends on your record and the circumstances of the arrest.
How a DWI case is defended
A DWI charge is not a conviction. Every part of the case can be challenged:
- The stop. The police need a lawful reason to stop your vehicle. If the stop was unlawful, the evidence that followed can be suppressed.
- The field sobriety tests. These tests are subjective, and performance can be affected by injury, fatigue, medication, footwear, road conditions, and nerves.
- The breath test. The machine must be properly maintained and calibrated, the operator properly trained, and the test properly administered — including the observation period before the test. The maintenance and calibration records are evidence, and they are not always in order.
- The blood test. Blood draws, chain of custody, and laboratory procedures can all be challenged.
- Rising blood alcohol. Your blood alcohol content at the time of driving may have been lower than at the time of the test, because alcohol continues to absorb after your last drink.
A former prosecutor knows how these cases are built — because he used to build them. James reviews the discovery — the police reports, the breath test records and maintenance logs, any video, and any blood or urine results — before advising a client on how the case should be handled. A plea should only be taken if it is actually in your interest. Some cases should be tried. James has tried hundreds of cases, including DWI cases that ended in a not guilty verdict after trial.
Why hire James Pascarella for a Long Island DWI
- He was a prosecutor. As a former Assistant District Attorney in the Suffolk County DA’s office, he knows how prosecutors build a DWI case, what evidence matters, and where a case is weak — and he uses that knowledge for the people he defends.
- He is in these courts almost every day. Nassau and Suffolk courtrooms are his working territory, and he has earned the respect of the judges, prosecutors, and defense attorneys who appear in them.
- Criminal defense is all he does. No other practice areas, no divided attention — and he does all the work on the cases himself. He does not hand your case to someone else, because he knows how important it is to his clients.
- He is selective about the cases he takes, and he gives each one his personal attention. His clients get his cell phone number. Most of his clients are clients for life.
- His experience runs wider than DWI. He has tried hundreds of cases — from DWI and drug offenses to assault, domestic violence, theft, sex crimes, and complex white-collar and federal matters — in state court and in federal court, in the Eastern District of New York (Central Islip and Brooklyn) and the Southern District of New York (Manhattan), and he has tried cases in the United Kingdom, including a not guilty verdict after trial in Manchester Crown Court in November 2026.
Frequently asked questions
I was arrested in one county but live in the other. Where is my case?
In the county where the arrest happened, in the court for that charge — not where you live. The county pages above set out which court hears each kind of case in Suffolk and in Nassau.
Will I go to jail for a first DWI on Long Island?
A first-offense DWI carries up to one year in jail, but there is no mandatory minimum. Whether jail is a real risk depends on your blood alcohol content, whether there was an accident or injury, your record, and how the case is handled.
Can I still drive to work?
Possibly. Your license is typically suspended at arraignment, but a conditional license through the Impaired Driver Program can permit limited driving for work, school, and medical appointments, and a hardship hearing can be requested at arraignment if the suspension would cause an extreme hardship. Neither is automatic, and the timing matters — this is one of the first things a lawyer should sort out.
What if I refused the breath test?
Refusal triggers a separate DMV case with a one-year revocation and a $500 civil penalty, and you have only 15 days to request a DMV refusal hearing. If you refused, call a lawyer right away — the deadline does not wait for the criminal case.
Which office should I call?
Either. Call the Suffolk office at (631) 789-3476 or the Nassau office at (516) 741-3476 — you will reach the same lawyer, and he will tell you which court your case is in and what happens next.
Free consultation: call (631) 789-3476 in Suffolk County or (516) 741-3476 in Nassau County. If you were arrested for DWI on Long Island, call now. The earlier a lawyer is involved, the more can be done — the DMV deadlines, the license suspension at arraignment, and the evidence in the case do not wait. Emergency contact: (516) 848-4649.
Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.