Suffolk Office:
(631) 789-3476
Nassau Office:
(516) 741-3476
Emergency Number:
(516) 848-4649
AVAILABLE 24/7
Suffolk Office:
(631) 789-3476
Nassau Office:
(516) 741-3476
Emergency Number:
(516) 848-4649
AVAILABLE 24/7

Suffolk County White-Collar Crimes Lawyer

A white-collar case in Suffolk County rarely begins with an arrest. It begins with a subpoena for records, an audit that turns into something else, a visit from investigators who say they “just have a few questions,” or a letter telling you that you are the target of a grand jury investigation. By the time charges are filed, the prosecution has usually been building the case for months — out of bank records, tax returns, emails, and ledgers. What you do at the beginning, before you have said anything to anyone, often matters as much as anything that happens in the courtroom.

James Pascarella is a former Assistant District Attorney who spent 26 years in criminal law and has tried hundreds of cases. He served in the Suffolk County District Attorney’s office, including time in its White Collar Crime Division — he has investigated and prosecuted these cases from the inside, and he knows how they are put together. Criminal defense is all he does. He has been selected to Super Lawyers every year from 2016 through 2026, and to the National Trial Lawyers Top 100.

The lawyer you choose can change the outcome of your case. White-collar cases are built over months, on paper — and they are defended the same way, by a lawyer who knows how the prosecution put the file together, because he used to put them together himself.

The white-collar charges in New York

White-collar charges are almost always felonies, and they are built on paper. The charges filed most often in Suffolk County are:

  • Grand Larceny, Penal Law Article 155. Stealing property — including money taken by deception, false pretenses, or embezzlement from an employer. The degree is set by the amount: fourth degree, over $1,000 (a class E felony, § 155.30); third degree, over $3,000 (a class D felony, § 155.35); second degree, over $50,000 (a class C felony, § 155.40); first degree, over $1 million (a class B felony, § 155.42). Amounts taken over time, in a single scheme, are added together.
  • Scheme to Defraud, §§ 190.60, 190.65. A systematic, ongoing course of conduct intended to defraud more than one person and obtain property from them. Second degree is a class A misdemeanor; first degree — ten or more intended victims, or more than $1,000 obtained — is a class E felony.
  • Enterprise Corruption, § 460.20. Participating in a structured criminal enterprise — a group with a pattern of criminal activity — knowing of the enterprise and intending to participate in its affairs. A class B felony. Aggravated enterprise corruption (§ 460.22) is a class A-I felony. This is New York’s state-law answer to racketeering, and prosecutors reach for it in organized fraud and theft cases.
  • Falsifying Business Records, §§ 175.05, 175.10. Making or causing a false entry in the business records of an enterprise, or erasing a true one, with intent to defraud. Second degree is a class A misdemeanor; first degree — where the intent includes committing or concealing another crime — is a class E felony.
  • Offering a False Instrument for Filing, §§ 175.30, 175.35. Knowingly presenting a false document to a government office, knowing it will become part of the official record. Second degree is a class A misdemeanor; first degree, with intent to defraud the state or a political subdivision, is a class E felony.
  • Forgery, §§ 170.10, 170.15. Making or altering a written instrument — a check, a deed, a contract, a signature — with intent to defraud. Second degree is a class D felony; first degree is a class C felony.
  • Identity Theft, §§ 190.78–190.80. Assuming another person’s identity to obtain money, credit, or goods — from a class A misdemeanor (third degree) to a class D felony (first degree).
  • Money Laundering, Article 470. Conducting financial transactions with the proceeds of criminal activity, knowing what the money is. Charged in four degrees, up to a class B felony.
  • Criminal Tax Fraud, Tax Law §§ 1801–1806. Tax fraud acts — false returns, failure to file, failure to pay over collected tax — charged in five degrees under the Tax Law, from a class A misdemeanor to a class B felony, depending on the amount of tax involved. The Attorney General and the District Attorney both prosecute these cases, and the Martin Act gives the Attorney General separate authority over securities fraud.
  • Federal charges. The same conduct is often charged federally: wire fraud and mail fraud (18 U.S.C. §§ 1343, 1341 — each carrying up to 20 years), bank fraud (§ 1344), conspiracy, money laundering, and tax evasion (26 U.S.C. § 7201). Federal cases from Suffolk County are heard in the Eastern District of New York.

The penalties

The felony classes carry these maximums for a first offender: a class E felony, up to four years; a class D felony, up to seven years; a class C felony, up to fifteen years; a class B felony, up to twenty-five years. A prior felony conviction raises the floor substantially.

Jail is a real and serious consequence. There is a persistent myth that white-collar defendants do not go to prison. They do — and in recent years the trend has run the other way, with judges and prosecutors treating white-collar crime more harshly than they once did. A felony fraud conviction can mean years in state prison, and a federal white-collar sentence can run longer still. But in a white-collar case, the sentence is only part of the exposure:

  • Restitution. The court can order repayment of what was taken, on top of any prison sentence.
  • Fines and forfeiture. Felony fines can reach double the amount gained, and the prosecution can pursue forfeiture of assets it claims are the proceeds of the offense — bank accounts, real property, business interests.
  • The collateral consequences. A felony fraud conviction ends careers built on trust: professional licenses, securities and insurance licenses, government contracts, and positions of financial responsibility. For non-citizens, it can mean deportation. These consequences are part of what the defense has to plan around from the start.

Where your Suffolk County white-collar case will be heard

  • Suffolk County Court, Riverhead. Felony white-collar cases are prosecuted here after indictment by a grand jury.
  • First District Court, Cohalan Court Complex, Central Islip. Cases begin here with arraignment; misdemeanor-level charges, such as second-degree falsifying business records, are heard here.
  • Federal court. Federal cases from Suffolk County are prosecuted in the Eastern District of New York, which sits in Central Islip and Brooklyn. James also practices in the Southern District of New York, in Manhattan, and handles federal criminal cases throughout the country.

Many white-collar cases are investigated by the Suffolk County District Attorney’s office — including its white-collar and economic crime units — sometimes with the New York Attorney General. James knows these offices and how they evaluate a case, because he worked in one of them.

What happens in a white-collar case in Suffolk County

  1. The investigation. Subpoenas for bank and business records, interviews of employees and associates, sometimes a search warrant or an audit referral from the Tax Department. The subject of the investigation is often the last to know. If investigators contact you, what you say before you have a lawyer can become the strongest evidence in the case.
  2. The grand jury. Felony charges require an indictment. A target who receives notice has the right to testify before the grand jury — a decision with real risks and real advantages, made with counsel, on a short deadline.
  3. Arrest and arraignment. White-collar arrests are frequently arranged as a surrender through counsel rather than a public arrest. Bail and travel and business restrictions are set at arraignment.
  4. Discovery. These cases are documents — sometimes hundreds of thousands of pages. The defense reviews the records the case is actually built on, often with a forensic accountant, looking for what the documents do not prove.
  5. Motions and negotiation. After discovery, the defense tests the indictment and the evidence through motions. How the case should proceed — by plea or by trial — is evaluated on specifics: the amount of loss, the defendant’s role, and what the records actually show. James works to get the best result the case allows.
  6. Trial. Some cases should be tried — particularly where the dispute is over intent. The prosecution must prove you intended to steal or defraud; sloppy bookkeeping, bad business judgment, and a failed business are not crimes. James has tried hundreds of cases, including complex financial cases.

Defenses in a white-collar case

White-collar cases are won on the documents and on intent:

  • Intent. Almost every white-collar charge requires proof that you acted knowingly and with intent to defraud. Money that was lost is not money that was stolen. Authorization, reliance on accountants and counsel, and an open set of books all speak to intent.
  • The amount. The degree of the charge — and much of the sentencing exposure — turns on the amount of loss or gain. Prosecutors aggregate and attribute; the defense examines transaction by transaction what is actually proven.
  • The investigation itself. Search warrants, subpoenas, and recorded interviews can be challenged, and statements made to investigators without counsel are examined for what was actually asked and answered.
  • Restitution and what is at stake. In many cases the practical fight is not only about the charge — it is about the amount of money claimed, the assets seized, and the license or business that a conviction would end. In the largest case of this kind James has handled, the Attorney General seized $9 million in cash and assets and charged his client with enterprise corruption and other felonies; after a year and a half of negotiation, $8.7 million was returned and the client pled to a low-level misdemeanor — no felony conviction, no jail, and no probation. In another case, a prominent business owner charged with grand larceny and failure to pay taxes ended with no criminal conviction at all.

A former prosecutor — one who served in the White Collar Crime Division — knows how these cases are built, because he used to build them. James looks for the same weaknesses a prosecutor would worry about, and uses them for the person he defends.

Why hire James Pascarella for a Suffolk County white-collar case

  • He prosecuted white-collar crime. As an Assistant District Attorney in Suffolk County, he served in the White Collar Crime Division. He knows how financial investigations are run, how prosecutors value a case, and where the proof is thin.
  • He is in Suffolk courts every day. He has built relationships with judges, prosecutors, and defense attorneys across New York — and earned their respect.
  • Criminal defense is all he does. No other practice areas, no divided attention — and he does all the work on the cases himself. He does not hand your case to someone else, because he knows how important it is to his clients.
  • He is selective about the cases he takes, and he gives each one his personal attention. His clients get his cell phone number. Most of his clients are clients for life.
  • He has tried hundreds of cases — from DWI and drug offenses to assault, domestic violence, theft, sex crimes, and complex white-collar and federal matters — in state court and in federal court, in the Eastern District of New York (Central Islip and Brooklyn) and the Southern District of New York (Manhattan).

Frequently asked questions

Investigators came to my office and said they just want to talk. Should I?
Not without a lawyer. Investigators investigating you are building a case, and anything you say can be used — including in a charge of making false statements if they believe you were untruthful. You are allowed to decline and to have counsel present. Call a lawyer first; the conversation can happen later, on advice, if it should happen at all.

I received a grand jury subpoena or a target letter. What does that mean?
A subpoena means the grand jury wants records or testimony in an active investigation. A target letter means the government considers you a target — someone it believes committed a crime. Both have short deadlines and real consequences for how they are answered. This is the stage at which a lawyer can sometimes still affect whether charges are brought at all.

Why does the amount of money matter so much?
Because the amount drives the case. In New York, the dollar figure sets the degree of a grand larceny charge — over $1,000, over $3,000, over $50,000, over $1 million — and in federal court the loss amount is central to the sentencing guidelines. Prosecutors add up transactions across months or years and attribute the total to the defendant. Examining what is actually proven, transaction by transaction, is a central part of the defense.

What if the case is federal?
Federal white-collar cases are investigated by federal agents and prosecuted by the U.S. Attorney’s office, under sentencing guidelines that make the amount of loss central. James practices in the Eastern District of New York (Central Islip and Brooklyn) and the Southern District of New York (Manhattan), and handles federal criminal cases in other states as well.


Free consultation: call (631) 789-3476 in Suffolk County or (516) 741-3476 in Nassau County. If you are under investigation or have been charged with a white-collar crime in Suffolk County, call now. The earlier a lawyer is involved, the more can be done — in an investigation, the first conversation and the first subpoena response can shape the entire case. James’s Suffolk office is at 888 Veterans Memorial Highway, Suite 530, Hauppauge. Emergency contact: (516) 848-4649.

Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Visit Us On FacebookVisit Us On Linkedin