A domestic violence arrest in Suffolk County usually starts with a phone call — an argument, a neighbor dialing 911, a spouse or partner who wanted the police to calm things down, not to make an arrest. But once the police arrive, the decisions are no longer yours. Suffolk County and Nassau County both have a mandatory arrest policy on domestic calls — when the police come, an arrest follows. And at arraignment the judge will almost always issue an order of protection — which can order you out of your own home and away from your children before anything has been proven. A domestic violence charge affects your home, your family, your job, and your right to own firearms, all at the same time.
James Pascarella is a former Assistant District Attorney who spent 26 years in criminal law and has tried hundreds of cases. Criminal defense is all he does. He appears in Suffolk County courtrooms on a daily basis, and he is well known and respected throughout the Suffolk County court system. He has been selected to Super Lawyers every year from 2016 through 2026, and to the National Trial Lawyers Top 100.
The lawyer you choose can change the outcome of your case. In a domestic case, the outcome follows you home — to your house, your children, and your record — which is why who represents you matters from the very first appearance.
The domestic violence charges in New York
“Domestic violence” is not a single charge. It is a set of ordinary criminal charges brought against a family or household member — a spouse or former spouse, a partner, someone you live with or have a child with, or a relative. The charges most often filed in Suffolk County are:
- Assault in the Third Degree, Penal Law § 120.00. Intentionally or recklessly causing physical injury. A class A misdemeanor — the most common assault charge in domestic cases.
- Assault in the Second Degree, § 120.05. Causing serious physical injury, or injury with a weapon or dangerous instrument. A class D felony.
- Criminal Obstruction of Breathing or Blood Circulation, § 121.11. Applying pressure to the throat or neck, or blocking the nose or mouth. A class A misdemeanor.
- Strangulation in the Second Degree, § 121.12. Obstructing breathing or blood circulation and causing stupor, loss of consciousness, or physical impairment. A class D felony. Strangulation in the First Degree, § 121.13, causing serious physical injury, is a class C felony. Prosecutors charge strangulation aggressively, sometimes on thin medical evidence.
- Menacing in the Second Degree, § 120.14. Placing another person in reasonable fear of injury or death, including by displaying a weapon. A class A misdemeanor. Menacing in the third degree (§ 120.15) is a class B misdemeanor.
- Criminal Contempt in the Second Degree, § 215.50. Violating an order of protection — including by a phone call, a text, or showing up somewhere you were ordered to stay away from. A class A misdemeanor.
- Criminal Contempt in the First Degree, § 215.51. Violating an order of protection with aggravating conduct — threats, intimidation, repeated violations, or a prior contempt conviction. A class E felony. Aggravated Criminal Contempt, § 215.52, causing physical injury in the course of a violation, is a class D felony.
- Aggravated Family Offense, § 240.75. A specified misdemeanor committed against a family or household member by someone with a qualifying prior conviction within five years. A class E felony — it turns a new misdemeanor into a felony based on the old case.
- Stalking, §§ 120.45–120.60. A course of conduct directed at a specific person, from a class B misdemeanor (fourth degree) to a class D felony (first degree).
- Endangering the Welfare of a Child, § 260.10. Knowingly acting in a manner likely to be injurious to a child under 17 — often charged when children were present during an incident, even if no child was touched. A class A misdemeanor.
- Harassment and Aggravated Harassment, §§ 240.26, 240.30. Harassment in the second degree is a violation, not a crime; aggravated harassment in the second degree — threats and repeated communications — is a class A misdemeanor.
Orders of protection: the part that changes your life immediately
The criminal charge is only half of a domestic case. The other half is the order of protection:
- Temporary order at arraignment. In nearly every domestic case, the judge issues a temporary order of protection at the first court appearance. A full stay-away order bars you from your home and from any contact with the protected person — no calls, no texts, no messages through friends or family, no showing up at their workplace. A refrain-from order allows contact but prohibits further offenses. Which one you get matters enormously, and it is decided at arraignment, on the first day.
- A parallel Family Court case. The same events can also be brought as a family offense case in Family Court under Article 8 of the Family Court Act, with its own order of protection. In Suffolk County, related criminal, family, and custody matters can be heard together in an Integrated Domestic Violence part, before one judge.
- A final order lasts for years. On a felony conviction, a final order of protection can run up to eight years; on a class A misdemeanor, up to five years (CPL § 530.13). It is renewable and enforceable in every state.
- Violating the order is a new crime. Any contact the order prohibits — even contact the other person invites — can be charged as criminal contempt. Until a judge modifies the order, the order controls, not the other person’s wishes.
- Firearms. An order of protection requires the surrender of firearms, and a domestic violence conviction — even a misdemeanor — can permanently cost you your right to own them under federal law.
Where your Suffolk County domestic case will be heard
- First District Court, Cohalan Court Complex, Central Islip. Misdemeanor domestic cases are heard here, and felony cases begin here with arraignment — where the temporary order of protection is issued.
- Suffolk County Court, Riverhead. Felony domestic cases — second-degree assault, strangulation, aggravated contempt — are prosecuted here after indictment.
- Family Court, Central Islip and Riverhead. Family offense petitions and custody matters arising from the same events are heard here, sometimes together with the criminal case in the Integrated Domestic Violence part.
- Town and Village courts. Some misdemeanor arrests by local police begin in the local court, from Huntington and Babylon to the Hamptons.
James appears in all of these courts regularly. He knows how the Suffolk County District Attorney’s office handles domestic cases — how it evaluates them, and what it does when the complaining witness’s account starts to change.
What happens after a domestic violence arrest in Suffolk County
- The call and the arrest. Police respond to a domestic call. If they believe a crime occurred — and in a felony case, if the law requires it — someone is arrested. It is often the person who did not make the call.
- Arraignment and the temporary order of protection. Usually within 24 hours. Charges are read, bail or release is decided, and the temporary order of protection issues. This is the moment your living arrangements and contact with your children can change.
- The second case. The complaining witness may also file in Family Court, and child protective services may become involved if children were present. These cases move on separate tracks and have to be handled together.
- Discovery. The prosecution must turn over the evidence: the 911 recording, body-camera and dash-camera video, photographs of any injuries, medical records, the incident reports, and the complaining witness’s statements — including the ones that do not match.
- Hearings and motions. The defense tests the evidence — whether the statements were lawfully obtained, whether the proof supports the degree charged, and whether the order of protection should be modified so a client can return home or see his children.
- Plea or trial. A case can be resolved by a plea, or it can be tried — and in a domestic case the decision carries more than the sentence, because a domestic conviction has consequences for custody, employment, professional licenses, and firearms that an ordinary misdemeanor does not. The decision should be made on the evidence, after the accounts have been tested. James works to get the best result the case allows. In one case James handled, a husband charged during a contentious divorce, on allegations his wife made to gain the upper hand, had his case dismissed after cross-examination and the evidence presented at a pre-trial hearing exposed what was behind them.
- Sentencing. If convicted, the sentence can include jail or prison, probation, a batterers’ intervention or anger-management program, fines — and a final order of protection that can last for years.
Defenses in a domestic violence case
Domestic cases are usually built on one person’s account. That account can be tested:
- Self-defense. New York law permits you to defend yourself (Penal Law § 35.15). The person who called 911 first is not automatically the victim.
- False or exaggerated allegations. It happens often: a domestic violence charge is filed in the middle of a divorce, and the legal system itself becomes leverage. An arrest and an order of protection can hand one side the house, the children, and the upper hand in the divorce proceedings — before a single allegation has been tested. When an accusation surfaces at the same time as a divorce filing or a custody dispute, the timing is part of the case. Motive matters, and it can be shown.
- Inconsistent accounts. The 911 call, the first statement to police, the Family Court petition, and the testimony often differ. Each version is evidence, and the differences are the defense.
- The injury proof. Assault requires proof of physical injury — substantial pain or impairment. Photographs, medical records, and the absence of either are all part of the case. Strangulation charges in particular are sometimes brought with little medical support.
- The complaining witness who recants. It happens often — but it does not end the case. The prosecution can and does proceed on the 911 call, the body-camera video, and the first statements. A recantation has to be handled carefully, and never by contact that violates the order of protection.
A former prosecutor knows how these cases are built — because he used to build them. James looks for the same weaknesses a prosecutor would worry about, and uses them for the person he defends.
Why hire James Pascarella for a Suffolk County domestic violence case
- He was a prosecutor. As a former Assistant District Attorney, he knows how domestic cases are charged, what evidence matters, and where a case is weak.
- He is in Suffolk courts every day. He has built relationships with judges, prosecutors, and defense attorneys across New York — and earned their respect.
- Criminal defense is all he does. No other practice areas, no divided attention — and he does all the work on the cases himself. He does not hand your case to someone else, because he knows how important it is to his clients.
- He is selective about the cases he takes, and he gives each one his personal attention. His clients get his cell phone number. Most of his clients are clients for life.
- He has tried hundreds of cases — from DWI and drug offenses to assault, domestic violence, theft, sex crimes, and complex white-collar and federal matters — in state court and in federal court, in the Eastern District of New York (Central Islip and Brooklyn) and the Southern District of New York (Manhattan).
Frequently asked questions
The other person wants to drop the charges. Can they?
No. Once the police make an arrest, the case belongs to the District Attorney, not to the complaining witness. The prosecution can continue even if the other person asks to withdraw the complaint or refuses to cooperate — using the 911 recording, the police observations, and the original statements. What the complaining witness wants still matters, and it is one of several things an experienced lawyer works with, but no one should assume the case will simply go away.
Can I go home, or call my children?
That depends on the order of protection. A full stay-away order means no — not to the home, and no contact of any kind, including through relatives. Violating it is a new crime, even if the other person invites the contact. A lawyer can ask the court to modify the order — to permit contact with your children, or third-party visitation — and that request should be made early and properly, in court.
Will this affect my divorce or custody case?
Almost certainly. An arrest and an order of protection change who lives in the home and who has the children while everything is pending, and the criminal case and the Family Court case influence each other. That is also why false allegations are made in custody disputes — and why the criminal defense has to be run with the family case in view.
I was the one who was attacked. Why was I arrested?
It happens more often than people expect. Police arriving at a chaotic scene have to decide quickly, and the person who called first — or who has the more visible complaint — is not always the aggressor. Self-defense is a complete defense in New York, but it has to be established with evidence: injuries, witnesses, recordings, and the sequence of events. That work starts immediately.
Free consultation: call (631) 789-3476 in Suffolk County or (516) 741-3476 in Nassau County. If you were arrested on a domestic violence charge in Suffolk County, call now. The earlier a lawyer is involved, the more can be done — the order of protection is issued at arraignment, and the arrangements for your home and your children are decided in the first days. James’s Suffolk office is at 888 Veterans Memorial Highway, Suite 530, Hauppauge. Emergency contact: (516) 848-4649.
Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.