Suffolk Office:
(631) 789-3476
Nassau Office:
(516) 741-3476
Emergency Number:
(516) 848-4649
AVAILABLE 24/7
Suffolk Office:
(631) 789-3476
Nassau Office:
(516) 741-3476
Emergency Number:
(516) 848-4649
AVAILABLE 24/7

Suffolk County Drug Crimes Lawyer

A drug arrest in Suffolk County can mean anything from a misdemeanor to one of the most serious felonies in New York law. The charge depends on the drug, the amount, and whether the police claim you intended to sell it — and the line between one degree and the next can be a matter of grams. Many drug cases begin with a stop — of a car, or of a person on the street — and the search that followed it. Whether that search was lawful is often the first question in the case. Sometimes it is the whole case.

James Pascarella is a former Assistant District Attorney who spent 26 years in criminal law and has tried hundreds of cases. Criminal defense is all he does. He appears in Suffolk County courtrooms on a daily basis, and he is well known and respected throughout the Suffolk County court system. He has been selected to Super Lawyers every year from 2016 through 2026, and to the National Trial Lawyers Top 100.

The lawyer you choose can change the outcome of your case. Drug cases turn on details — a stop, a search, a warrant — and the lawyer who knows how to attack them can keep the prosecution’s evidence out of the case entirely.

The drug charges in New York

Drug offenses are charged under Article 220 of the Penal Law. The degree rises with the type of drug, the weight, and any evidence of selling:

  • Criminal Possession of a Controlled Substance in the Seventh Degree, Penal Law § 220.03. Simple possession of a controlled substance — cocaine, heroin, fentanyl, oxycodone, methamphetamine, and others. A class A misdemeanor.
  • Criminal Possession in the Fifth Degree, § 220.06. Possession with intent to sell, or possession of 500 milligrams or more of cocaine. A class D felony.
  • Criminal Possession in the Fourth Degree, § 220.09. One-eighth of an ounce or more of a narcotic drug, among other thresholds. A class C felony.
  • Criminal Possession in the Third Degree, § 220.16. Possession of a narcotic drug with intent to sell it, or one-half ounce or more. A class B felony.
  • Criminal Possession in the Second Degree, § 220.18. Four ounces or more of a narcotic drug. A class A-II felony.
  • Criminal Possession in the First Degree, § 220.21. Eight ounces or more of a narcotic drug. A class A-I felony — the most serious drug charge in New York.
  • Criminal Sale of a Controlled Substance, §§ 220.31–220.43. Sale charges run from the fifth degree (a class D felony) to the first degree (a class A-I felony, for the sale of two ounces or more of a narcotic drug). Selling a narcotic drug at all is at least a class B felony. Sale in or near school grounds, § 220.44, is also a class B felony.
  • Operating as a Major Trafficker, § 220.77. Directing a drug organization or profiting from drug sales on a large scale. A class A-I felony.
  • Related charges. Criminally using drug paraphernalia (§ 220.50) and criminal possession of a hypodermic instrument (§ 220.45) are class A misdemeanors. Criminal sale of a prescription for a controlled substance (§ 220.65) is a class C felony.

Cannabis is different. Since 2021, adults 21 and over may lawfully possess up to three ounces of cannabis or 24 grams of concentrated cannabis (Penal Law Article 222). Possessing more than that is a violation or, above sixteen ounces, a crime: criminal possession of cannabis in the third degree (a class A misdemeanor), the second degree (a class E felony, over five pounds), or the first degree (a class D felony, over ten pounds). Selling cannabis without a license is still a crime, and selling to a minor is a felony.

The penalties

Drug felonies carry determinate prison sentences under Penal Law §§ 70.70 and 70.71. For a person with no prior felony conviction, the ranges are:

Charge level Prison range (first felony offender)
Class A misdemeanor Up to 1 year in county jail
Class E felony 1 to 1½ years
Class D felony 1 to 2½ years
Class C felony 1 to 5½ years
Class B felony 1 to 9 years
Class A-II felony 3 to 10 years
Class A-I felony 8 to 20 years

A prior felony conviction makes you a second felony drug offender, and the ranges rise sharply. Fines are on top of prison — up to $100,000 on a class A-I felony — and the court can order forfeiture of money and property the prosecution claims came from drug activity. At the lower levels, probation and treatment-based dispositions are possible, and for eligible defendants there are diversion programs (see below). A drug conviction also carries consequences beyond the sentence: a criminal record, and for non-citizens, the risk of deportation.

Where your Suffolk County drug case will be heard

  • First District Court, Cohalan Court Complex, Central Islip. Misdemeanor drug cases are heard here, and felony cases begin here with arraignment and preliminary proceedings.
  • Suffolk County Court, Riverhead. Felony drug cases are prosecuted here after indictment by a grand jury.
  • Town and Village courts. Some misdemeanor possession arrests made by local police — in Suffolk’s towns and villages, from Huntington and Babylon to the Hamptons — begin in the local court.

James appears in all of these courts regularly, and he knows how the Suffolk County District Attorney’s office evaluates drug cases at each level — what it will offer, what it will not, and where it worries about its own evidence.

What happens after a drug arrest in Suffolk County

  1. The stop and the search. Most drug arrests follow a traffic stop, a street encounter, a search warrant, or a search of a home or car. The legality of that search is examined in almost every drug case.
  2. Arrest and arraignment. You are charged and brought before a judge, usually within 24 hours. Bail or release is decided, and the felony complaint or misdemeanor information is filed.
  3. Grand jury and indictment. A felony case cannot proceed to trial unless a grand jury indicts, or the charge is reduced. You have the right to testify before the grand jury — a decision to make with a lawyer, early.
  4. Discovery. The prosecution must turn over the evidence: police reports, body-camera and surveillance video, search warrant applications, laboratory reports identifying the substance and its weight, and records of any informant or undercover officer involved.
  5. Suppression hearings. If the stop or search was unlawful, the defense moves to suppress the drugs. Without the drugs, the prosecution usually has no case. James has had drugs suppressed many times over the years — and when the evidence is suppressed, the case often cannot go forward.
  6. Diversion. Eligible defendants can be considered for judicial diversion or drug court — treatment under court supervision, in place of a prison sentence. In another Suffolk County case, a charge of driving while impaired by drugs was dismissed after almost a year of negotiation, and the client pled to a traffic infraction.
  7. Plea or trial. A case can be resolved by a plea, or it can be tried. Which path is right depends on the evidence — starting with whether the search was lawful — on the level of the charge, and on your circumstances, and it should not be decided before the discovery has been reviewed and the weaknesses in the case tested. James has tried hundreds of cases, and he works to get the best result the case allows.
  8. Sentencing. If convicted, the sentence follows the ranges above, and can include prison, probation, fines, and forfeiture.

Defenses in a drug case

A drug charge is not a conviction. The prosecution has to prove every part of its case, and drug cases have specific weak points:

  • The search. The police need a lawful basis to stop you, to search your car or home, and to open closed containers. Search warrants can be challenged — the application, the informant’s reliability, and how the warrant was executed. Evidence obtained unlawfully is suppressed.
  • The laboratory proof. The prosecution must prove the substance is what it claims, and how much of it there was. The weight is measured on the whole mixture, not the pure drug — which makes the lab work, the scales, and the chain of custody worth examining in every felony case.
  • Possession itself. Possession means knowing possession — dominion and control. Drugs found in a shared car, a shared apartment, or someone else’s belongings are not automatically yours, and presence alone is not possession.
  • Intent to sell. Intent is often inferred from packaging, scales, cash, or messages. Those inferences can be challenged — personal-use quantities and personal possessions are not proof of selling.
  • Diversion and treatment. For defendants whose case is driven by addiction, judicial diversion under CPL Article 216 and the Suffolk County drug court can put treatment under court supervision in place of a prison sentence.

A former prosecutor knows how these cases are built — because he used to build them. James looks for the same weaknesses a prosecutor would worry about, and uses them for the person he defends. He has also defended drug cases in federal court, including a federal drug conspiracy case in which a client facing a mandatory minimum of ten years received a sentence of probation.

Why hire James Pascarella for a Suffolk County drug case

  • He was a prosecutor. As a former Assistant District Attorney, he knows how drug cases are investigated and charged, what evidence matters, and where a case is weak.
  • He is in Suffolk courts every day. He has built relationships with judges, prosecutors, and defense attorneys across New York — and earned their respect.
  • Criminal defense is all he does. No other practice areas, no divided attention — and he does all the work on the cases himself. He does not hand your case to someone else, because he knows how important it is to his clients.
  • He is selective about the cases he takes, and he gives each one his personal attention. His clients get his cell phone number. Most of his clients are clients for life.
  • He has tried hundreds of cases — from DWI and drug offenses to assault, domestic violence, theft, sex crimes, and complex white-collar and federal matters — in state court and in federal court, in the Eastern District of New York (Central Islip and Brooklyn) and the Southern District of New York (Manhattan).

Frequently asked questions

Will I go to prison for a first drug offense?
It depends on the level of the charge. A misdemeanor possession charge does not ordinarily mean prison, and at the lower felony levels probation and treatment dispositions are possible. The class A felonies carry mandatory prison. What is realistic in your case depends on the drug, the weight, your record, and the strength of the evidence — starting with whether the search was lawful.

The drugs were found in a car or a house, not on me. Can I still be charged?
Yes — the prosecution can charge possession based on dominion and control over the place where the drugs were found. But it has to prove you knew the drugs were there and exercised control over them. Being present, or owning the car, is not by itself enough.

Can the drugs be thrown out?
If the police obtained them through an unlawful stop, search, or warrant, yes. The defense files a suppression motion and the judge holds a hearing at which the officers testify. If the judge grants the motion, the prosecution is left without its central evidence, and the case is often dismissed or reduced.

Is marijuana still a crime in New York?
Possession of up to three ounces by an adult is lawful. Possession above the limits in Article 222, and any unlicensed sale, can still be charged — and driving while impaired by cannabis is charged the same as impairment by any other drug.


Free consultation: call (631) 789-3476 in Suffolk County or (516) 741-3476 in Nassau County. If you were arrested on a drug charge in Suffolk County, call now. The earlier a lawyer is involved, the more can be done — the grand jury deadline, the suppression issues, and the evidence in your case do not wait. James’s Suffolk office is at 888 Veterans Memorial Highway, Suite 530, Hauppauge. Emergency contact: (516) 848-4649.

Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Visit Us On FacebookVisit Us On Linkedin