A DWI arrest in Suffolk County is a criminal charge, not a traffic ticket. A first offense is a misdemeanor. It can mean a fine, a revoked license, an ignition interlock device, and a criminal record — and your license is usually suspended at your very first court appearance, before the case is decided. In some circumstances the prosecutor could be looking for jail, and probation is also a possible outcome. What you do in the first days after the arrest matters, because the deadlines start running immediately. There is no right or wrong answer when it comes to taking the chemical test — it depends on the situation, and it is a decision to make with a lawyer, not alone on the side of the road. And if you have just been arrested, call me. My cell is (516) 848-4649, and if it is an emergency I do not care what time it is — 3 in the morning included. That is what the number is for.
James Pascarella is a former Assistant District Attorney who spent 26 years in criminal law and has tried hundreds of cases. Criminal defense is all he does. He appears in Suffolk County courtrooms on a daily basis, and he is well known and respected throughout the Suffolk County court system. He has been selected to Super Lawyers every year from 2016 through 2026, and to the National Trial Lawyers Top 100.
The lawyer you choose can change the outcome of your case. The same charge and the same facts can end very differently depending on who is standing next to you — a lawyer who knows where a DWI case is weak, and how to use it.
The DWI charges in New York
New York has several different impaired-driving charges, and which one you face changes the penalties. All of them are charged under Vehicle and Traffic Law § 1192:
- Driving While Ability Impaired by Alcohol (DWAI), VTL § 1192(1). A blood alcohol content generally between .05% and .07%. A traffic infraction, not a crime — but it still carries a fine, a license suspension, and a mandatory Impaired Driver Program.
- DWI — per se, VTL § 1192(2). A blood alcohol content of .08% or higher, shown by a chemical test. A misdemeanor for a first offense.
- DWI — common law, VTL § 1192(3). Driving in an intoxicated condition, proven by observations and other evidence even without a breath or blood test result.
- Aggravated DWI, VTL § 1192(2-a). A blood alcohol content of .18% or higher. Still a misdemeanor for a first offense, but with higher fines and a longer license revocation.
- Driving While Ability Impaired by Drugs, VTL § 1192(4). Impairment by drugs, or by drugs combined with alcohol. A misdemeanor for a first offense, with the same penalty range as a DWI.
- Refusing the chemical test, VTL § 1194. Refusal is not itself a crime, but it triggers a separate DMV case: a one-year license revocation and a $500 civil penalty for a first refusal, on top of the criminal case.
- Felony DWI. A second DWI within 10 years is a felony. A DWI with a child under 16 in the vehicle is a felony even on a first offense, under Leandra’s Law.
Where your Suffolk County DWI case will be heard
Suffolk County is large, and where your case is heard depends on the charge and where the arrest happened:
- First District Court, Cohalan Court Complex, Central Islip. Misdemeanor DWI cases — and the arraignment for most DWI arrests in Suffolk County — are heard here. This is where your license is typically suspended at arraignment, and where the early decisions in your case are made.
- Suffolk County Court, Riverhead. Felony DWI cases, including second offenses within 10 years and Leandra’s Law cases, are prosecuted here after indictment.
- Town and Village courts. DWI arrests made by local police in Suffolk’s towns and villages — from Huntington and Babylon to the Hamptons — often start in the local town or village court before moving to District Court.
James appears in all of these courts regularly. He knows which court your case will be in, what that court expects, and how the Suffolk County District Attorney’s office handles DWI cases at each stage.
What happens after a DWI arrest in Suffolk County
- Arrest and chemical test. You are arrested, usually after a traffic stop, and asked to take a breath, blood, or urine test. You may be held until arraignment.
- Arraignment. Usually within 24 hours. The charges are read, you enter a plea, and the judge decides bail or release. Under New York’s prompt suspension law, your license is typically suspended at arraignment if the chemical test showed a blood alcohol content of .08% or higher, or if you refused the test. A hardship hearing can be requested if the suspension would cause an extreme hardship.
- The DMV case. Separate from the criminal case, the Department of Motor Vehicles can suspend or revoke your license. If you refused the chemical test, you have a limited time — 15 days — to request a DMV refusal hearing. Missing that deadline can cost you the hearing.
- Discovery and investigation. The prosecution must turn over the evidence: the police reports, the breath test records and maintenance logs, any video, and the results of any blood or urine test. This is where many DWI cases are won or lost.
- Plea or trial. A plea should only be taken if it is actually in your interest. Your lawyer’s job is to work for a better plea or a dismissal: finding the weaknesses in the case, challenging the evidence, and using them to get the charge reduced, the case dismissed, or a plea that is actually worth taking. Some cases should be tried. James has tried hundreds of cases, including DWI cases that ended in a not guilty verdict after trial.
- Sentencing. If convicted, the sentence can include jail — jail is a possibility even on a misdemeanor, and a first DWI carries up to one year in jail — as well as a fine, probation, the Impaired Driver Program, a Victim Impact Panel, and an ignition interlock device. Your license is revoked for at least six months on a first DWI conviction.
Defenses in a DWI case
A DWI charge is not a conviction. Every part of the case can be challenged:
- The stop. The police need a lawful reason to stop your vehicle. If the stop was unlawful, the evidence that followed can be suppressed.
- The field sobriety tests. These tests are subjective, and performance can be affected by injury, fatigue, medication, footwear, road conditions, and nerves.
- The breath test. The machine must be properly maintained and calibrated, the operator properly trained, and the test properly administered — including the observation period before the test. The maintenance and calibration records are evidence, and they are not always in order.
- The blood test. Blood draws, chain of custody, and laboratory procedures can all be challenged.
- Rising blood alcohol. Your blood alcohol content at the time of driving may have been lower than at the time of the test, because alcohol continues to absorb after your last drink.
A former prosecutor knows how these cases are built — because he used to build them. James looks for the same weaknesses a prosecutor would worry about, and uses them for the person he defends.
Why hire James Pascarella for a Suffolk County DWI
- He was a prosecutor. As a former Assistant District Attorney, he knows how prosecutors build a DWI case, what evidence matters, and where a case is weak.
- He is in Suffolk courts every day. He has built relationships with judges, prosecutors, and defense attorneys across New York — and earned their respect.
- Criminal defense is all he does. No other practice areas, no divided attention — and he does all the work on the cases himself. He does not hand your case to someone else, because he knows how important it is to his clients.
- He is selective about the cases he takes, and he gives each one his personal attention. His clients get his cell phone number. Most of his clients are clients for life.
- He has tried hundreds of cases — from DWI and drug offenses to assault, domestic violence, theft, sex crimes, and complex white-collar and federal matters — in state court and in federal court, in the Eastern District of New York (Central Islip and Brooklyn) and the Southern District of New York (Manhattan).
Frequently asked questions
Will I go to jail for a first DWI in Suffolk County?
A first-offense DWI carries up to one year in jail, but there is no mandatory minimum. Many first offenders do not serve jail time, particularly when the case resolves by plea. Whether jail is a real risk depends on your blood alcohol content, whether there was an accident or injury, your record, and how the case is handled.
Will I lose my license?
Probably, at least temporarily. Your license is typically suspended at arraignment, and a conviction means a revocation of at least six months. Many first offenders can get a conditional license through the Impaired Driver Program, which allows limited driving for work, school, and medical appointments.
Should I have refused the breath test?
That decision is already made, and it cannot be undone. Refusal triggers a separate DMV case with a one-year revocation and a $500 civil penalty, and you have only 15 days to request a DMV refusal hearing. If you refused, call a lawyer right away — the deadline does not wait for the criminal case.
What if I was arrested by a town or village police department?
Your case may start in that town or village court. The charge and the penalties are the same, but the court, the prosecutor, and the procedures are local. James handles DWI cases in Suffolk’s town and village courts as well as in Central Islip and Riverhead.
Free consultation: call (631) 789-3476. If you were arrested for DWI in Suffolk County, call now. The earlier a lawyer is involved, the more can be done — the DMV deadlines, the license suspension at arraignment, and the evidence in the case do not wait. Emergency contact: (516) 848-4649.
Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.